This process is traditionally called purva paksha, a distinctive feature of exegesis in sanskrit, and in rajiv s work it is given a new importance. Some reflections on rajiv malhotras being different gerald james larson let me begin by reiterating what i said in my prepublication comments about the book, namely, that rajiv malhotras being different. It is done by reversing the gaze by making east the adjudicator in our understanding of the west. Rajiv malhotra and mark tully discuss being different. What do you think about rajiv malhotra and his work. I agree with him that the euroamerican gaze directed at asia has not only been destruc. Beware of the rise of hindu supremacists in america. I am posting below my report from the recent american academy of religion annual conference where my book being different was the subject of a special panel discussion. Christianity, history and the dharma in rajiv malhotras being different. Its concerns are mainly metaphysical, cultural and civilizational.
The other thing which is long term but will surely produce results is to fight every seat and say that we represent a different culture. Gier rajiv malhotra has been a leading spokesperson defending the indian philosophical and religious traditions as he views them. An indian challenge to western universalism rajib malhotra in being different. Rajiv malhotra is a researcher, author, speaker, thinker and public intellectual on contemporary issues as they relate to civilization, crosscultural encounters, spirituality, and science. Rajiv malhotra s work is a kind of yajna that reverses the gaze upon the west through the lens of indian knowledge systems. Opinion a rebuttal to rajiv malhotra, by an elite leftist goon activist a talk recently delivered by the selftaught social scientist at tiss devolved into a hail of accusations. Though most western readers are hardly familiar with the long history of renaissances within the indic civilization and there have been many a new renaissance in indic thought and culture is gathering force. Join infinity foundation australia discussion forum. An indian challenge to western universalism is a 2011 book by rajiv malhotra. Rajiv malhotra debates mark tully, eminent bbc correspondent who has lived most of his life in india and is highly regarded as a lover of indian civilization. Mark tully discusses rajiv malhotras book being different. Rajiv malhotra is back with another book bound to create a controversy the new book valiantly attempts to counter what the writer calls the western view of ancient indian texts. Rajiv malhotra s being different is a path breaking book filled with original perspectives on both indian and western civilizations. Defending hinduisms philosophical unity, the battle for sanskrit, and the newly released book academic.
Join rajivs egroup join and participate in rajiv malhotras online discussion groups on yahoo. Rajiv malhotra, founder of infinity foundation, is an internationally known researcher and public intellectual on current affairs as they relate to civilizat. By accident or design, the book is part of a wider trend of establishing sanskrit. Rajiv emphasizes the importance to prevent ayurveda from losing its authenticity and becoming digested into western medicine. An indian challenge to western universalism kindle edition by rajiv malhotra. Rajiv malhotras lecture on academic colonization delivered at uberoi foundation 2010 we use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. A critique of rajiv malhotras being different nicholas f. Wikipedia page of the book being different an indian challenge to western universalism, thinker and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer and looking at the west from the dharmic point of view.
Rajiv malhotras being different is a path breaking book filled with original perspectives on both indian and western civilizations. Praise for being different by rajiv malhotra this highly original book leads its reader on an epic journey of selfdiscovery especially for those of us in the west. Rajiv malhotra is a researcher, writer, speaker and public intellectual on current affairs as they relate to civilizations, crosscultural encounters, religion and science. Take, for example, mr rajiv malhotra and his book, breaking india. Rajiv malhotra and mark tully discuss being different rajiv malhotra. Mr rajiv malhotra presents his own lived experience or. A critique of rajiv malhotras being different find. Western interventions in dravidian and dalit faultlines. The book reverts the gaze of the western cultures on india, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer, by looking at the west from a dharmic point of view. Instead, in the case of rajiv malhotra and his western critics, there has been. Rajiv malhotra, religion, india, news, congress, sonia gandhi, rahul gandhi, priyanka gandhi, islam, quran, muhammad, zakir naik, islam, hindusim, hindu, sanatan.
Wikipedia page of the book being different an indian challenge to western universalism, thinker and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer and looking at the west from. Mr rajiv malhotra presents his own lived experience or purvapaksha and his study of american ideas. Online resource, database, crowd sourcing, and expert feedback on contemporary hinduism, dharmic india, and topics covered in breaking india, being different. Stephens college in delhi and went for postgraduate studies in physics and then computer science to the usa. Rajiv malhotra has explained them very well in this book with the help of simple tables and charts. Gier 1 international journal of hindu studies volume. Stephens college in delhi and did his postgraduate education in physics and then computer science in the usa. An indian challenge to western universalism by rajiv malhotra at amazon. Rajiv malhotras insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not with mere tolerance is even more pertinent today because the. An indianamerican entrepreneur, philanthropist and community leader, he has devoted himself, for the last ten years, to clarifying the many misperceptions about indic traditions in america and amongst indians. Beijing being different by master rajiv malhotra is a bombshell of a book because of its provocative proposition and its adding hundreds of new sanskrit terminologies to our english vocabulary. Files are available under licenses specified on their description page. Whether the author of being different has achieved a grand. It is a primer on how looking at hinduism through a western lens is inadequate and flawed.
The account below deals with just one of the three panelists, brian pennington, the man who wrote the book. Being different rajiv malhotra infinity foundation. Controversial and selfstyled hinduism scholar rajiv malhotra is back with a new book. An indian challenge to western universalism, indras net. Being a junior partner and just as waiting for crumbs. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page information wikidata item cite this page.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc. Born in 1950, rajiv malhotra is an indianamerican researcher, writer, speaker and public intellectual on current affairs as they relate to civilizations, crosscultural encounters, religion and science. Whichever side of the fence one may be, the battle for sanskrit, offers a. It is well and clearly written and of exceptional clarity. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading breaking india. Lets pay attention to what the smart guys are saying out of concern for the universal good. Rajiv malhotras insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not with mere tolerance is even more pertinent today because the notion of. The groundbreaking work on being homosexual in americaavailable again only from penguin classics and with a new foreword by dan savage originally published in 1971, merle millers on being different is a pioneering and thoughtprovoking book about being homosexual in. Download pdf on being different free online new books.
An indian challenge to western universalism is a 2011 book by rajiv malhotra, an indianamerican author, philanthropist and public speaker, published by harpercollins. It challenges western categories of knowledge as well as. The process of critique, the acknowledgement of error, and apology are more in tune with the rituals of scholarship. Rajiv malhotra, author and hindu intellectual, is the man who developed the breaking india theory in his eponymous 2011 book.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Stephens college in delhi and went for a phd in physics to university of. Rajiv malhotras latest book, being different, is at this the forefront of this renaissance. Review rajiv malhotra, authour of being different hopes to set the terms for a deeper and more informer engagement between dharmic and western civilizations. Rajiv malhotra being different the eastwest dichotomy. India was a super power and the british conspired to destroy it. An indian challenge to western universalism 2011 is important for two reasons.
This book has nothing to do with converting others. Checkout vibhinnata laghu sanskaran summary of book vibhinnata. There can be no single universalism, even if it assimilates or, in the authors words, digests, elements from other civilizations kapila vatsyayan in being different. Rajiv malhotra is the founder and president of infinity foundation. Dalits is hypocritical unless one also speaks out against atrocities being perpetrated against the. I have explained in detail in being different that christianitys mandatory belief in nicene creed violates the worldview in which yoga is based. Digestion, indic grand narrative, kumbha mela, purva paksha, western universalism, being different, invading the sacred, breaking india, indras net, battle for sanskrit, hinduphobia, indian think tank, indian intellectual. A critique of rajiv malhotras being different academia.
A rebuttal to rajiv malhotra, by an elite leftist goon. Some reflections on rajiv malhotras being different pdf, international journal of hindu. Malhotra has written prolifically in opposition to the academic study of indian history and society, especially hinduism, as it is conducted by scholars and university faculty of the west, which, he maintains. How rajiv malhotra became the ayn rand of internet hindutva the new jerseybased ideologues blogs and books have powered large parts of contemporary hindutva. Rajiv malhotra, an indian american author, philanthropist and public speaker, published by harper. Being different breaks new ground in that direction. Being different an indian challenge to western universalism is a 2. Rajiv malhotra is back with another book bound to create a. This is a must read for all students of comparative religion and for those who want to truly understand hinduism, and more. Western interventions in dravidian and dalit faultlines kindle edition by malhotra, rajiv, neelakandan, aravindan. January 9 my encounter with brian pennington at the recent aar rajiv malhotra. All structured data from the file and property namespaces is available under the creative commons cc0 license.
69 356 564 686 210 1292 125 1375 578 401 645 404 1389 1071 1108 337 167 210 489 1464 519 805 560 751 159 740 753 100 231 672 1120 432 665 1347 545 1482 333